Pumpkin Spice and Everything Nice: Fall 2022 Indy Coffee Guide

It’s the most wonderful time of year for coffee lovers in Indy - the time when fall coffee menus drop. Each year the drinks get more and more unique and it’s so fun to see local coffee shop’s twists on classics or to see if pumpkin spice or apple cider is the winner. For all you PSL lovers, I’ve notated which shops are serving up your fave with a 🎃 to keep it easy for ya!

  • Amberson - P.S.L.

  • Best Friends Coffee and Bagel - Vampire Blood, Candy apple, Witch's Brew, Pumpkin Cheesecake

  • Blue Collar Coffee Co. - Pumpkin Chai, Maple Latte, Spiced Chai Mocha, Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃, Pumpkin Cold Brew

  • Calvin Fletcher’s - Masala Latte

  • Chronic Coffee - Pumpkin Pie Cold Brew

  • Coffeehouse Five - Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃, Pumpkin Pancake Latte, White Pumpkin Latte, Pumpkin Brûlée Late, Pumpkin Chai

  • Command Coffee - Maple Brown Sugar Macchiato, Toasted Marshmallow Latte, Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃, Candy Apple Frappe, Chocolate Chai

  • Commissary - Apple Cider Rosemary Latte, Problem Child

  • Dry Bones Mudhouse - Toffee Caramel Crunch Latte, Apple Pie Tea Latte, Bad Apple Latte

  • Foundation Coffee Company -

  • Founders Ground - Caramel Apple Freeze, Pumpkin Pie Freeze

  • Geist Coffee - Campfire Latte, Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃, Maple Macchiato, Pumpkin Chai Latte, Red Cappuccino

  • GoldLeaf - Apple of My Chai, I'd Like S'more Mocha, Down to Butterscotch, Golden Lumberjack

  • Helm Coffee Roasters - Maple Brown Sugar Cold Brew

  • Indie Coffee Roasters - Hazy Pumpkin, The Yzma, The Cobbler

  • Java House - Pumpkin Cold Foam Cold Brew, Dirty Pumpkin Pie Chai, Pumpkin Spice Frappe, Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃, Bonfire Brew

  • Kaffeine Coffee - Fall Teas

  • Lincoln Lane - Midwest Sun, Caramel Apple Spice, Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃, Salted Caramel Maple

  • Mansion Society - Basic Witch, The Goldie, Sweater Weather, The Girl Scout, Matchacita, The Lou, The Duke, Bread & Butter, Chai This Spice

  • The Mocha Nut - Pumpkin Pie Latte

  • MOTW Coffee - Maple Spice, Brown Sugar White Mocha, Peppermint White Mocha

  • Neidhammer - The Spiced Vanilla Pear Flash Brew, The Apple Butter Latte, The LumberJack Latte, The Pumpkin Patch Latte, Apple Cider Slushies

  • Noble Coffee and Tea - Pumpkin Pie Frappe, Butter Beer

  • Parlor Public House - Nana’s Teeth, Godfather

  • Provider - The Spiced Demerara Latte

  • Prufrock Coffee Co - Persimmon Latte, Rosemary Latte

  • Quills Coffee - The Lantern, The Woodsman, The Goatman, The Road Less Traveled

  • Rabble Coffee - Peachy Jean, Purple Phase

  • Rivet Coffee - Angry Gourd Latte, Cozy Caramel Latte, Apple Pie Chai

  • Roasted in the Village - Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃

  • Rose and Lois - Pumpkin Pie Latte, Chocolate Banana Bread Latte, Carmel Apple Latte, Carmel Apple Cold Brew

  • Schoolhouse 7 Cafe - Harvest Moon Latte, Cozy Cold Brew with Foam, Pumpkin Pie Chai

  • Silver Linings Coffeehouse - Pumpkin Spice Latte 🎃, Pumpkin Iced Coffee topped with Cinnamon Sugar Cold Foam, Friday Night Lights Latte, Apple Cider Chai, BlackBerry Caramel Crisp Latte, Pumpkin Chai Latte

  • The Spark - Pumpkin Pie Latte, Butter Pecan Chai, Apple Butter Latte, Strongly Worded Email Latte, Pumpkin Pie Cold Foam

  • The Well Coffeehouse - Black Cat Latte

  • Tinker Coffee - Bourbon Caramel Latte, Maple Miso Latte, Chaider, Bonfire Latte, Em’s Pumpkin Spice Special

Local CultureShay McCoycoffee in indianapolis, fall coffee, seasonal drinks, best seasonal coffee in indy, local seasonal drinks, local seasonal coffee, indy coffee, indianapolis coffee, amberson coffee, amberson coffee indy, best friends coffee and bagel, best friends coffee and bagel indy, blue collar coffee co, blue collar coffee co indy, bovaconti, bovaconti indy, calvin fletchers indy, calvin fletcher's, calvin fletcher's coffee company, chronic coffee, chronic coffee indy, coffeehouse five, coffeehouse five indy, command coffee, command coffee indy, commissary indy, dry bones mudhouse, dry bones mudhouse indy, foundation coffee company, foundation coffee company indy, founders ground, founders ground indy, geist coffee company, geist coffee indy, goldleaf savory sweet, goldleaf indy, helm coffee roasters, helm coffee roasters indy, indie coffee roasters, indie coffee roasters indy, java house, java house indy, kaffeine coffee, kaffeine coffee indy, lincoln lane, lincoln lane indy, mansion society, mansion society indy, the mocha nut, the mocha nut indy, monon coffee co, monon coffee co indy, motw coffee indy, motw coffee, neidhammer indy, neidhammer coffee, noble coffee and tea, noble coffee and tea indy, parlor public house, parlor public house indy, provider, provider coffee, provider indy, prufrock coffee indy, prufrock coffee company, quills, quills coffee, quills coffee indy, rabble coffee, rabble coffee indy, rivet coffee, rivet coffee indy, roasted in the village indy, roasted, rose and lois indy, rose and lois, schoolhouse 7 cafe, schoolhouse 7 cafe indy, silver linings coffeehouse, silver linings coffeehouse indy, the spark, the spark indy, the well coffeehouse, the well coffeehouse indy, tinker coffee, tinker coffee indy1 Comment